May 15, 2025
Inside the NCAA Baseball Selection Process: A Roundtable with Committee Chairman Jay Artigues
The D1Baseball PodcastAbout this episode
In this special edition of the D1Baseball podcast, host Mike Rooney, along with podcast regulars Mark Ethridge, Kendall Rogers, and Aaron Fitt, welcome Jay Artigues, the athletic director at Southeastern Louisiana and current chairman of the NCAA Baseball Selection Committee. The discussion covers the selection process for the 64-team NCAA baseball tournament, the importance of the "eye test" versus RPI, and the challenges of regional placements. Jay also addresses common misconceptions about the committee's work, talks about transparency, and explains how subjective factors are balanced against statistical metrics. The roundtable provides an insider's view of the intricate and often contentious process of selecting the NCAA Baseball Field of 64! 00:00 Introduction and Special Guest Announcement 00:59 Jay Artigues' Coaching Background and Selection Committee Role 02:48 Selection Committee Process and Challenges 05:32 Geographical Placement and Scheduling Issues 11:51 Evaluating Teams: Metrics and Eyeball Test 21:22 Final Thoughts and Committee Insights 25:58 Conclusion and Farewell The D1Baseball Podcast is brought to you by Academy Sports + Outdoors—your go-to destination for everything you need this baseball season. Whether you’re gearing up for game day or sharpening your skills in the offseason, Academy has the bats, gloves, cleats, protective gear, training equipment, and apparel to help you bring it home for less. With everyday low prices and a huge selection of top brands like Easton, Rawlings, and Wilson, Academy makes it easy to step up to the plate with confidence. Shop in-store or online at Academy.com and get ready to play ball! D1Baseball is the #1 source for college baseball. Subscribe to our show to get the best college baseball podcast straight to your Apple Podcasts or Spotify feed all year round. Reviews and 5-star ratings are greatly appreciated! And if you’re a super-fan of college baseball, you can subscribe and watch all of our podcasts on the D1Baseball YouTube Channel. See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info .