EP 269 - The Best Fitness Tracker in 2025 – Garmin Fenix vs. Whoop

In this podcast, we put the latest lineup of hunting and fitness wearables through the Mindful Hunter scoring system—breaking down everything from battery life and GPS performance to real-world hunt data and sleep tracking. If you’re looking for a no-nonsense review that cuts through the marketing fluff, this one’s for you. We start with a full overview of the scoring system and testing methodology, followed by a deep dive into how each watch performed across a variety of metrics that actually matter in the field. From price and display quality to weather resistance and app integration, we leave no stone unturned. This review also includes a detailed section on performance and health tracking, as well as exclusive hunt data analysis and training metrics that show how these devices hold up under pressure.+ If you’re serious about your gear and want honest insights from someone who’s been there, this breakdown will give you the clarity you need to make the right choice. 0:00 – Intro 1:58 – Scoring System 2:28 – Mindful Hunter Outfitting 3:26 – Price 4:46 – Battery 7:23 – Bands 8:51 – Display 9:53 – Weather Resistance 10:34 – GPS 11:26 – App Integration 13:29 – Descriptive Totals 13:37 – Swarovski ATX 85 Giveaway 14:27 – Sensors 15:28 – Sensitivity 16:28 – Performance Tracking 17:41 – Health Tracking 18:42 – Sleep Tracking 19:02 – Hunt Data 24:31 – Training Data 25:38 – Tracking Totals 25:54 – Final Score 26:21 – Recommendations Jay Nichol jay@mindfulhunter.com https://www.mindful-reviews.com/ https://www.mindfulhunter.com/ Forged In The Backcountry https://forgedinthebackcountry.com/ Merch https://www.mindfulhunter.com/shop Newsletter https://www.mindfulhunter.com/contact IG https://www.instagram.com/mindful_hunter/ Podcast https://www.mindfulhunter.com/podcast Free Backcountry Nutrition Guide https://www.mindfulhunter.com/tools