About this episode
On Thanksgiving Day 1934, police in Tulsa, Oklahoma found the dead body of John Gorrell Jr., a Kansas City dental student, slumped behind the wheel of his car, which had come to a stop at a downtown intersection. Gorrell had been shot in the head twice with his own gun and his wallet and other valuables were missing, leading police to conclude he had been killed in a botched robbery. Just one day later, the residents of Tulsa were shocked to learn that Gorrell hadn’t been killed by a robbery, but by his friend Phil Kennamer, and his motive wasn’t robbery. At the peak of the Great Depression, newspaper reports of violent crime were nothing new. In this case, however, the victim was the son of a prominent local physician and his killer the son of a well-known US District Court judge. The privileged backgrounds of the victim and killer were enough to captivate the residents of Tulsa, but as the strange details of the story slowly emerged in the days that followed, the case quickly grew from local sensation to national fascination. In the weeks and months that followed, countless front pages (and then some) were dedicated to the lurid details of what the press soon dubbed the “Society Gang Killing;” a story of disaffected youth who, bored with their wealth and privilege, turned to crime and violence for the sake of entertainment and excitement. Thank you to the incredible Dave White of Bring Me The Axe Podcast for Research! References Biscup, Walter. 1935. "Verdict of jury leaves punishment of Gorrell's slayer to Judge Hurst." Tulsa World , February 22: 1. Frates, Kent. 2014. "The Society Gang Killingg." This Land , July 15. Freese, Jim. 2016. Murder in the Name Of Love: The Phil Kennamer Trial. Tulsa, OK: Freese Publishing . Miami Daily News-Record. 1934. "Sheriff refuses to act on Phil Kennamer's version of case, involving associates." Miami Daily News-Record , December 13: 1. —. 1934. "Doubt cast on gang theory in Tulsa slaying." Miami Daiy News-Record , December 3: 1. Morrow, Jason. 2015. Deadly Hero: The High Society Murder that Created Hysteria in the Heartland. Tulsa, OK: Independent. Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat. 1935. "Counsel declares he could not tell right from wrong." Muskogee Daily Phoenix and Times-Democrat , February 15: 1. New York Times. 1934. "Death car driver a suicide in Tulsa." New York Times , December 10: 38. —. 1935. "Girl takes stand to Aid Kennamer." New York Times , February 16: 30. —. 1935. "Kennamer reveals 'extortion letter'." New York Times , January 27: 15. —. 1935. "Kennamer tells of fatal shooting." New York Times , February 19: 10. Phillips, Harmon. 1935. "Kennamer Case goes on aftwer threat of mistrial." Tulsa Tribune , February 13: 1. —. 1935. "Phil Kennamer back to jail with 25 years in prison as penalty for Gorrell killing." Tulsa Tribune , February 24: 1. —. 1935. "State blocks quick opinion by doctor that Kennamer shot youth while insane." Tulsa Tribune , February 16: 1. Tulsa Tribune. 1934. "Anderson tells plan of Kennamer Trial." Tulsa Tribune , December 15: 1. —. 1935. "New clues seen in notes from Phil Kennamer." Tulsa Tribune , January 3: 3. —. 1934. "Phil Kennamer inisists slaying his own actions." Tulsa Tribune , December 2: 5. —. 1934. "Police call Born suicide." Tulsa Tribune , December 10: 1. —. 1935. "Opposing Kennamer case legal batteries promise fiery clash of courtroom tactics." Tulsa Trribune , January 23: 7. Tulsa World. 1935. "Judge Kennamer weeps as he describes Phil's abnormalities." Tulsa World , February 16: 1. Cowritten by Alaina Urquhart, Ash Kelley & Dave White (Since 10/2022) Produced & Edited by Mikie Sirois (Since 2023) Research by Dave White (Since 10/2022), Alaina Urquhart & Ash Kelley Listener Correspondence & Collaboration by Debra Lally Listener Tale Video Edited by Aidan McElman (Since 6/2025) Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.