Jim Bowden Says Pirates Fans Should Quit. Here’s Why He’s Wrong

On the latest episode of NS9LIVE!, the conversation centered on what it means to be a Pittsburgh Pirates fan in today’s baseball landscape and why recent commentary around small-market teams struck such a nerve. The crew reacted strongly to Jim Bowden’s suggestion that frustrated fans should simply “retire” or switch allegiances, pushing back on the idea that fandom is disposable or conditional on winning. From there, the discussion shifted into real baseball questions, including the Pirates’ continued struggles to land impact hitters and the looming decision surrounding Munetaka Murakami. With Murakami required to sign by Monday or return to Japan, the panel debated the risk versus reward of investing heavily in an international power bat, diving into strikeout concerns, upside, age, and whether this is a gamble the Pirates should take. The episode also touched on trade possibilities, including Mark Vientos, and what actually qualifies as a meaningful move for a team desperate for offense. As always, NS9LIVE! blended strong opinions, analytics, humor, and fan perspective into an honest reflection of where the Pirates stand right now. Watch or listen to the full episode of NS9LIVE on YouTube or your favorite podcast platform and join the conversation with us. Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.